用户对欺骗性车载信息娱乐用户界面的感知
User Perceptions of Deceptive In-Vehicle Infotainment User Interfaces
Pedram MohajerAnsari (Clemson University) · Iwinosa Aideyan (Clemson University) · Anna Galeano (Clemson University) · Arjun Arunasalam (Florida International University) · Bart Knijnenburg (Clemson University) · Richard Brooks (Clemson University) · et al.
中文摘要
现代车辆大量收集驾驶员、乘客及车辆使用数据,隐私与同意决策日益通过信息娱乐软件进行。尽管暗黑模式(dark patterns)已在网页、移动端和电商界面中被广泛研究,但其在车载信息娱乐系统中的表现形式及用户感知仍知之甚少。通过 Android Automotive OS(AAOS)开展三阶段实证分析:第一,26 名 HCI 与隐私标注者对四家 OEM 的 AAOS 模拟器(Honda、Volvo、GM、Polestar)进行审计,在 65 条观察中记录 17 种暗黑模式类型;第二,100 名参与者的用户研究比较 GMC、Honda、Volvo 对五种暗黑模式的具体实现,发现实现方式影响用户感知;第三,49 名参与者的独立研究在简短教程前后对比车载与电商暗黑模式片段,显示车载的初始评分优势在指导后基本消失。研究揭示“复杂度悖论”:更隐蔽的暗黑模式更不易引发用户怀疑,因而可能更难识别。监管应不仅评估暗黑模式是否存在,还应评估其具体实现方式。
关键要点
- 01审计四家 OEM 的 AAOS 模拟器,记录 17 种暗黑模式类型、65 条观察。
- 02100 人用户研究表明同一暗黑模式的不同实现方式会影响用户感知。
- 0349 人对比研究显示教程后车载暗黑模式的评分优势基本消失。
- 04提出复杂度悖论:越隐蔽的暗黑模式越不易被怀疑、越难识别。
- 05监管建议:应评估暗黑模式的具体实现方式,而非仅看是否存在。
解读
尚无解读。
原始英文摘要
arXiv:2611.25195v1 Announce Type: new Abstract: Modern vehicles collect extensive data about drivers, passengers, and vehicle use, with privacy and consent decisions increasingly mediated through infotainment software. Although dark patterns have been widely studied in web, mobile, and e-commerce interfaces, little is known about how they appear in automotive infotainment systems or how users perceive them. We study this problem through Android Automotive OS (AAOS), conducting a three-phase empirical analysis. First, 26 HCI and privacy annotators audit four OEM AAOS emulators (Honda, Volvo, GM, and Polestar), documenting 17 dark-pattern types across 65 observations. Second, a user study with 100 participants compares OEM-specific implementations of five dark patterns across GMC, Honda, and Volvo, finding that implementation choices affect user perceptions. Third, an independent study with 49 participants compares automotive and e-commerce dark-pattern clips before and after a brief tutorial, showing that automotive's initial rating advantage largely collapses after instruction. Together, the studies identify a sophistication paradox: subtler dark patterns are less likely to trigger user suspicion and may therefore be harder to identify. These findings indicate that oversight should evaluate not just the presence but also the specific implementation of dark patterns.